A little about this place
About Carmelina Restaurant
Carmelina Restaurant in Milliken, Markham, serves Italian and Mediterranean-inspired pasta, risotto, seafood, steaks and starters. Menu highlights include Gourmet Bruschetta, PEI lobster crab cakes, pasta, and risotto. Expect a sit-down room with traditional decor, a baby grand piano and a cozy special-occasion atmosphere noted in the review sample. The direct Google sample repeatedly highlights the cozy ambience and distinctive dining-room setting.
Recurring cautions concern premium pricing, charges for items some diners expected to be included, and uneven food or service execution. Google Maps About directly lists a washroom, a wheelchair-accessible washroom, a free parking lot, free street parking and plenty of parking; Halal Food Pass has not independently inspected these amenities. Halal Food Pass lists this restaurant as halal; diners should confirm current sourcing and menu scope directly.
Signature dishes
- Gourmet Bruschetta
- PEI lobster crab cakes
- pasta
- risotto
HFP review summary
What diners mention
Research updated ·
4.4 / 5911 Google reviews · saved total
Saved ratings and review totals may have changed.
Rating breakdown at this snapshot
- 5 stars
585 585 - 4 stars
202 202 - 3 stars
65 65 - 2 stars
29 29 - 1 star
30 30
What people enjoy
- Cozy ambience and distinctive decor receive repeated praise Earlier sample: 2026-09-04
- Baby grand piano creates a special-occasion setting Earlier sample: 2026-09-04
- Broad pasta, seafood and steak menu Earlier sample: 2026-09-04
Things to keep in mind
- Price-to-value concerns recur in low-rated reviews Earlier sample: 2026-09-04
- Unexpected bread, water or service charges are repeatedly mentioned Earlier sample: 2026-09-04
- Food and service execution is described as inconsistent Earlier sample: 2026-09-04
Compiled by Halal Food Pass from public reviewer opinions. Experiences vary; these comments have not been independently verified.
Good to know before you go
What is on the Carmelina Restaurant menu?
The Carmelina Restaurant menu on this page lists 31 items across 5 sections, including Gourmet Bruschetta, PEI lobster crab cakes and pasta, checked September 2026. Prices shown come from the restaurant's own menu or direct-order channel as observed on that date; delivery-platform prices are labelled separately. The restaurant's own website is linked on this page as well. Menus change, so confirm current dishes with Carmelina Restaurant.
How much does food at Carmelina Restaurant cost?
Carmelina Restaurant's own menu or direct-order prices observed in September 2026 ranged from $10.00 to $75.00 CAD. This range covers the captured items and variants; larger platters or catering packs may be included. Prices are set by the restaurant and can change; the observed date is shown beside each price on this page.
What is Carmelina Restaurant known for?
Carmelina Restaurant's listed signature dishes include Gourmet Bruschetta, PEI lobster crab cakes, pasta, risotto.
